Firing Your Lawyer and Hiring a New One: A Client’s Guide
A client has the right to change attorneys at any time, with or without cause. This is a fundamental right that ensures clients are not trapped in a legal relationship with an attorney they no longer trust or who is not meeting their needs. The law recognizes that the attorney-client relationship is one of trust and confidence, and if that trust is lost, the client should be free to seek new representation.
Step-by-Step Guide to Replacing Your Attorney
Step 1: Understand Your Reasons and Document Them
Before you act, be clear about why you are dissatisfied. Is it a lack of communication, a disagreement on strategy, or a concern about competence? While you don’t need a “good” reason to fire your lawyer, having one can help you communicate with a potential new attorney. Documenting specific instances or issues can be helpful later.
Step 2: Find a New Attorney
This is the most crucial step. Do not fire your current attorney until you have a new one lined up and ready to take your case. Firing your lawyer without a replacement can leave you in a vulnerable position, especially if there are upcoming deadlines in your case.
- Research: Look for attorneys with experience in the specific area of law your case involves.
- Consultations: Many attorneys offer a free initial consultation. Use this time to discuss your case, your reasons for wanting to switch, and the potential challenges.
- Discuss the Transition: Ask potential new attorneys about their process for taking over a case. They should be able to explain how they will get the file from your old attorney and get up to speed.
Step 3: Inform Your Current Attorney in Writing
Once you have a new attorney confirmed, you must officially notify your current attorney that you are terminating their services. This should always be done in writing.
- Clarity and Simplicity: The letter should be direct and to the point. State that you are terminating the attorney-client relationship effective immediately.
- Request Your File: The letter should also formally request that the attorney transfer your entire case file to your new counsel. Be specific and include your new attorney’s name and contact information.
- Professionalism: Keep the tone professional. Avoid airing grievances or making accusations in the letter. A simple statement of termination is sufficient.
Step 4: Your New Attorney Takes Over
Your new attorney’s office will handle the formal communication with your old attorney’s office. This includes:
- Sending a “Substitution of Counsel” form: In many jurisdictions, a formal document must be filed with the court to inform them of the change in representation.
- Requesting the Case File: Your new attorney will follow up to ensure they receive the complete file, including all documents, pleadings, correspondence, and discovery materials.
Step 5: Settle the Financials
You are responsible for paying your former attorney for the work they have done up to the point of termination.
- Review Your Agreement: Look at the original fee agreement you signed. It should outline the terms for payment in case of termination.
- Itemized Bill: Ask your former attorney for a detailed, itemized bill of all the work they have performed on your case.
- Negotiate: If you believe the bill is unreasonable or if you had a flat-fee or contingency arrangement, you may need to negotiate the final payment. In some cases, a dispute over fees may need to be resolved through arbitration or a legal fee dispute program, depending on your state’s rules.
Important Considerations:
- Contingency Fees: If your original attorney was working on a contingency fee basis (they get a percentage of the settlement), they may be entitled to a portion of the final fee based on the work they performed. This is often negotiated between the old and new attorneys.
- Lien on the File: In some states, an attorney may be able to assert a “retaining lien” on your case file until their fees are paid. However, there are typically exceptions to this, especially if it would harm your case or if you post a bond or other security.
- Communication: Keep the lines of communication open and professional with both your old and new attorneys to ensure a smooth transition and minimize any disruption to your case.
Tools